Anti-statism refers to opposition to state intervention into personal, social or economic affairs. — Wikipedia.
Anti-Imperialism remains attractive to Leftists precisely because it mandates that anti-imps support whatever Popular Front-type formation happens to be in an antagonistic relationship toward a chosen imperial state; thus it requires little in the way of critical thinking. Anti-Imperialism is an unthinking person’s revolutionary (im)posture.
Another major problem with such an approach is that by always choosing to side with whoever you think opposes the chosen imperial state, you are permitting that imperial state to set the agenda for you. In a very real way, that state is then controlling your political behavior. Hatred is a form of bondage to the object. Also, of course, the enemy of my enemy is not always my friend, and is something only a simpleton would believe or a charlatan pretend.
A decade ago, the anti-imps of ANSWER supported Milosevic the ethnic cleanser. These days, American and European anti-imps express their solidarity with the clerical obscurantists and misogynists of Hamas and Hezbollah, and/or the Stalinists of the PFLP because they are resisting the militarist ethnic cleansing of the State of Israel. It doesn’t seem to bother the anti-imps too much that these gangs spend almost as much time fighting, kidnapping, torturing, and killing each other in order to consolidate their political and territorial hegemony.
“We must support Mugabe because he stands against imperialism” is precisely the lunacy I heard while a member of a hard left group. As for all the dead bodies piled up in mounds, well, they never talked much about that – and Stalin’s purges were of course never mentioned, much less criticized. Apparently they only oppose ruthless use of force when the other side is doing it.
Anarchist anti-imps are compelled to take sides in every dispute, desperate to find some group—any group—whose Revolutionâ„¢ they can support. Being activists, they have to Do Something; more often than not they get sucked into Popular Fronts (ANSWER—Worker’s World Party [Now, PSL]; World Can’t Wait—RCP), becoming more bodies at the latest march, at worst insisting—against all evidence to the contrary—that these cross-class fronts really are authentic grassroots progressive coalitions subject to direct democracy, and not under the control or sponsorship of Leninists at all.
That’s why such Leninist vanguard parties are doomed to failure. They can never become genuine mass organizations because by definition they only allow those in the leadership who toe their precise ideological line. So, there’s no real way for them to grow. (Nor do they really want to, the front group is primarily used for recruitment into the party.)
Anti-Imperialism is just as bankrupt today as it was in the ’40s and ’70s; it should be avoided as a label and position by any principled anti-statist.