Judge derails California High Speed Rail plans


A Superior Court judge has derailed Governor Jerry Brown plans to build his doomed, expensive, California High Speed Rail project. Brown desperately wants to satisfy two major constituencies, big labor (who will build it) and Wall Street (who will finance it.) One small snag, California doesn’t have the money, even as they continue to pretend they do.

California High Speed rail is sleazy pork barrel politics at its worst. It will cost upwards of $100 billion, under current estimates, and will not get people from San Francisco to Los Angeles faster than airports. It just won’t. HSR will be a ecological disaster in the Central Valley. There is no chance a high speed rail line will be built up the peninsula towards San Francisco because of vocal, well-funded opposition and the impossibility of constructing new tracks at any sane price because they must go above or below ground and not on the surface.

The judge ruled construction cannot begin because the State has no credible source of funding and further said they could not issue an $8.6 billion bond. Good.

As a practical matter, this means construction can’t start unless the state finds $25 billion or more in solid financing — which is highly unlikely given a ban on revenue guarantees to investors. Nor can it start until the state completes all environmental reviews for the initial 300-mile segment — which could take years.


  1. There was a time when you could literally get from the curb at LAX to the parking lot at Concord in an hour. And those PSA flights flew every hour or two. Ah, those were the days of air travel!

    Now, thanks to airline consolidation and our prominent but ineffective air travel security, you can barely get to the plane in an hour. Buchanan Field in Concord no longer has commercial passenger flights, leaving you to fly into much-less-convenient Oakland or (OMG!) SFO. Then you have to get into town.

    At an estimated 2:38 travel time between LA and SF, high-speed rail actually would be faster!

    • True, except it won’t be 2:38 because there’s no way it can travel at high speed through the densely packed SF peninsula. It can’t go on the ground because any collision with a car crossing when it shouldn’t would be horrific. So it has to go above or below ground. And that is hugely expensive.. Hugely. Plus NIMBYs abound there.

      So, if it ever gets built, it will travel at pokey speeds once it hits San Jose.

Comments are closed.